
This is a pretty interesting article about bad science journalism. It asks whose fault it is, the public, the journalists, or the scientists themselves. Ohh.. and this picture has nothing to do with anything.
In a report published today Britain's National Academy of Sciences has said slip ups in the past have led to distorted reporting of issues such as MMR and GM crops. Scientists often blame the media for distorted reporting of science stories. But does the misreporting have its origins in the research community? A couple of years ago, scientists organising a major European fertility meeting invited a researcher to present evidence that a group of women seeking fertility treatment were more likely conceive if they were hypnotised. It was a fantastic story and prominently reported across the world. The problem was that the research was dubious. The hypnotised group were much younger and so more likely to be fertile than - than the un-hypnotised group.
1 Comments:
Anytime someone tries to solve a problem, they are separating its aspects from the whole cloth of reality. This is why they hold that, “all things being equal…� one can expect such and such a result from the problem solving process.
When a scientist fails to disprove a hypothesis, they have separated a part of reality, and in failing to disprove it have said that this is not not so. Those unacquainted with the philosophical underpinnings of science will fail to recognize that there is a qualitative difference between “not not� and “is�—though math would hold that there is no difference as math is more religiously “absolute� in its attitude than “science.� When you tease apart reality to look within it, it is necessary to clarify and refine your understanding so as not to abuse context.
Such a will to clarification and understanding takes time and diligence, something most news consumers have too short an attention span to pursue, and news purveyors, wishing to serve their paying public, are wise to avoid.
Posted by Bill Churchill (05-12-06)
Fri May 12, 02:49:18 PM CDT
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home